This essay concerns some of these most recent scholarly trends regarding the historicity of Jesus' resurrection. I will note the emergence of almost a dozen different alternative theses that are variously suggested or favored by more than forty different scholars, some of whom endorse more than one theory. While some of these works are lesser known or more popularly written, others contain suggestions or assertions held by highly influential authors. There is an interdisciplinary flavor here, as well. Most of the critics are theologians or NT scholars, while a number of them are philosophers, along with a few others from diverse fields.
My effort here will attempt to categorize and list these natural hypotheses, including naming two alternative proposals that have so far eluded any generally recognized appellation. Hopefully, even this broad scholarly demarcation will serve the purpose of calling attention to the current skeptical trend, which may become more helpful if the recent trickle becomes a torrent.
* I have critiqued several versions of these recent naturalistic theories in a number of journal articles. For a detailed response to Evan Fales's rendition of the legend theory, see "On the Resurrection Appearances of Jesus," in Philosophia Christi 2d series/3 (2001): 76-87. Concerning G. A. Wells's form of the legend theory, see "A Summary Critique: Questioning the Existence of Jesus," Christian Research Journal 22 (Spring 2000): 54-56. (For a more detailed critique of both Wells and Michael Martin, see my The Historical Jesus, chap. 2.) On the hallucination theory, see "Explaining Away Jesus' Resurrection: The Recent Revival of Hallucination Theories," Christian Research Journal 23 (2001): 26-31, 47-49. For a response to a chief proponent of the illumination theory, see "The Early Christian Belief in the Resurrection of Jesus: A Response to Thomas Sheehan," Michigan Theological Journal 3 (Fall 1992): 105-27.
Introduction: While Christian beliefs are presumably much more widely known, especially in the Western world, some adherents to the major non-Christian religions also make claims that some of their historical rabbis, prophets, gurus or 'messiahs' rose from the dead. Judging from the relevant religious literature, it appears that such non-Christian claims are often ignored, perhaps because there is little awareness of them. Even if the existence of such beliefs is recognized, almost never is there any in-depth answer to the question of whether such claims could possibly be grounded in supernatural events of history.
This essay is an examination of several sample resurrection-claims in non-Christian religions from ancient to modern times. The primary emphasis will be placed on whether these claims can themselves be said to be historically based on supernatural occurrences. To pursue this goal, historical and other critical criteria will be applied to these religious beliefs. Lastly, a few comments will be addressed to the issue of whether these resurrection claims provide any apologetic basis for non-Christian belief systems.
Introduction: ...Since 1975, more than 1400 scholarly publications on the death, burial, and resurrection of Jesus have appeared. Over the last five years, I have tracked these texts, which were written in German, French, and English. Well over 100 subtopics are addressed in the literature, almost all of which I have examined in detail. Each source appeared from the last quarter of the Twentieth Century to the present, with more being written in the 1990s than in other decades. This contemporary milieu exhibits a number of well-established trends, while others are just becoming recognizable. The interdisciplinary flavor is noteworthy, as well. Most of the critical scholars are theologians or New Testament scholars, while a number of philosophers and historians, among other fields, are also included.
This essay is chiefly concerned with commenting on a few of these most recent scholarly trends regarding the resurrection of Jesus. I will attempt to do four things here, moving from the general to the specific. This will involve 1) beginning with some tendencies of a very broad nature, 2) delineating several key research trends, 3) providing a sample interpretation of these research trends from the works of two representative scholars, and 4) concluding with some comments on what I take to be the single most crucial development in recent thought. Regarding my own critics over the years, one of my interests is to ascertain if we can detect some widespread directions in the contemporary discussions?where are most recent scholars heading on these issues? Of course, the best way to do this is to comb through the literature and attempt to provide an accurate assessment.
For a variety of reasons, contemporary scholars widely conclude that after his death, Jesus' followers at least thought that they had seen appearances of the risen Jesus. Do the disciples' beliefs that they had witnessed resurrection appearances provide any clues as to what may really have occurred? The answer depends on how one accounts for these experiences. Here, where scholarship differs widely, three chief options prevail. In spite of these differences, it is my contention that this is the single most crucial aspect of the historical question.
Recent Perspectives on the Reliability of the Gospels. Originally published in the Christian Research Journal / vol. 28, no. 1, 2005.
Synopsis: "The usual attempts to defend the historical reliability of the New Testament are often fairly general in nature. These arguments are typically based on the quantity, quality, and early date of the available New Testament manuscript copies, additional considerations that favor the traditional authorship of the books, plus extra-biblical confirmation, along with a few archaeological discoveries. This case for the trustworthiness of the New Testament is often contrasted with ancient, classical Greek and Roman writings, which do not exhibit the same wealth of data. However, much less-known among conservatives is one of several, more recent and specific paths that is usually applied by critical scholars to the Gospel texts. Proceeding in a more analytic manner, one of these methods applies certain critical criteria of authenticity to particular texts, namely, to events and sayings that are reported in the four Gospels. These contemporary techniques have mined many gems that indicate the historical richness of the Gospel accounts, while illuminating many aspects of Jesus' life. After a brief overview of some traditional paths, our chief purpose in this essay is to outline several of these criteria of authenticity as applied to the Gospels. Many examples will illustrate the application of these principles."
"Seldom have recent scholars questioned or denied the historical existence of Jesus. Of the very few who have done so, G. A. Wells is probably the best known. In this article, I will outline and then respond to some of his major tenets.
"Before turning to this topic, I will first note that the vast majority of scholars, both conservative and liberal alike, generally disdain radical theses that question the very existence of Jesus. For example, theologian Rudolf Bultmann asserted, "By no means are we at the mercy of those who doubt or deny that Jesus ever lived." A[i].
"Historian Michael Grant termed the hypothesis that Jesus never lived an "extreme view." He charges that it transgresses the basics of historiography: "if we apply to the New Testament, as we should, the same sort of criteria as we should apply to other ancient writings containing historical material, we can no more reject Jesus' existence than we can reject the existence of a mass of pagan personages whose reality as historical figures is never questioned." Grant summarizes, after referring to Wells as an example: "modern critical methods fail to support the Christ-myth theory." These positions have been "annihilated" by the best scholars because the critics "have not succeeded in disposing of the much stronger, indeed very abundant, evidence to the contrary." A[ii] .
Explaining Away Jesus' Resurrection: The Recent Revival of Hallucination Theories - Christian Research Journal. Originally published in the Christian Research Journal / vol. 23, no. 4, 2001. Abstract: ?After almost a century of virtual dormancy, a number of naturalistic alternative hypotheses regarding Jesus' resurrection have appeared in recent publications. Similar to the situation at the end of the Nineteenth Century, hallucination and related subjective approaches are again the most popular among critics. We will survey several of these recent formulations. Then we will offer numerous critiques, both of such subjective approaches as a whole, as well as a couple of inclusive issues. We will argue that these alternative strategies fail to explain the historicity of Jesus' resurrection appearances for a host of reasons, even when judged by critically-accepted standards.?
Introduction: "Central to a Christian world view is the conviction that Scripture, both the Old and New Testaments, comprises God's word to us. What sort of basis can be produced to back this tenet? In this article, we will produce a major argument in favor of this doctrine. Then we will mention another avenue of defense that might be pursued. Interestingly, the latter might actually turn out to be the strongest argument.
"Before we begin, we must state a few crucial foundational truths that cannot be argued here and thus must be assumed for the purposes of this article. But they are well-established, as shown elsewhere in a host of publications.
1 It must be stated simply that Jesus was raised from the dead.
2 As a result, a strong case can be made in favor of the principle that God thereby verified Jesus' message.
3 Therefore, if Jesus taught the inspiration of the Scripture, then this would be a powerful argument for believers to do the same.
4 Further, the Gospel texts, in particular, are at least generally reliable documents when they relate Jesus' teachings.
5 We will now move on from here, outlining a couple of paths toward such a case for the inspiration of Scripture."
The Truth-And the Comfort-of the Resurrection . An edited version of this article was published in Decision, vol. 41, no. 4 (April 2000), pp. 8-10. (Published by Billy Graham Evangelistic Association).
... "Today, most scholars think that Paul provides the key testimony for Jesus' resurrection. We have a number of unquestioned writings from his pen. In them he passionately explains that he was converted by an appearance of the resurrected Lord (I Cor. 9:1; 15:8; Gal. 1:16). Jesus also appeared to many others (I Cor. 15:3-7), and His apostles were giving the same report as was Paul (15:11-15). Later, Peter, John, and James specifically approved Paul's Gospel message (Gal. 2:1-10).
"In explaining the content of his Gospel preaching, Paul chose words from ancient Jewish tradition. The message he had "passed on" to his listeners was precisely what he had "received" (I Cor. 15:3). It is widely held that Paul obtained this material from Peter and James during his first trip to Jerusalem about 35 AD. Paul got "acquainted" with Peter while staying with him for fifteen days (Gal. 1:18). Paul's term here means that he questioned or examined Peter, and the immediate context indicates that the subject was the Gospel message.
... "If God raised His Son then there was an answer to Debbie's suffering, even if I didn't know what it was! But I did know this much: if Jesus was raised, then Debbie would be raised someday, too (I Cor. 6:14; Phil. 3:21).
"It was sufficient to know that, because of Jesus' resurrection, we would be together again, and for all eternity! This is the force of resurrection faith for all who trust in Jesus Christ. This answer was sufficient in 1995 and it remains so today. Through all of my pain, this truth has never failed to comfort me, providing tremendous peace."
On the Resurrection Appearances of Jesus. Response to Evan Fales's approach to the resurrection of Jesus. Published in Philosophia Christi, vol. 3, n. 1. 2001, pp. 76-87.
Evidence for the Historical Jesus. Edited transcript from The John Ankerberg Show, 2000 (with permission). This edition is entirely reviewed and updated to June 2015 by Prof Gary Habermas.
Hailsham, Lord [Quintin McGarel Hogg] / 1st Baron Hailsham of St Marylebone, Lord Chancellor; son of 1st Viscount Hailsham
(1907-2001)
1st Baron Hailsham of St Marylebone, Lord Chancellor; son of 1st Viscount Hailsham. Read about Lord Hailsham here.
WORKS
The Door Wherein I Went. London: Collins, 1975. 311 pp., [1] leaf of plates: port.; 24 cm. Printed in Simon Greenleaf Law Review, n. 4. 1984. Introduction by John Warwick Montgomery.
The Evidence and authority of divine revelation: being a view of the testimony of the law and the prophets to the Messiah, with the subsequent testimonies. Second edition. London: Hamilton, Adams, and Co., 1834. Volume 1 of 2.
Volume 2 of 2.
Hale, Sir Matthew
(1609-1676)
Lord Chief Justice of England. Read about Hale here.
WORKS
Sir Matthew Hale's affectionate epistles to his children: With directions concerning the religious observation of the Lord's Day: To which is prefixed the life of the author. A new edition. Salisbury, 1788. 167 pp. Extract, first letter.
"EVERY morning, read seriously and reverently a portion of the Holy Scriptures, and acquaint yourselves with the history and doctrine thereof. It is a book full of light and wisdom, will make you wise to eternal life, and furnish you with directions and principles to guide and order your life safely and prudently. There is no book like the Bible for excellent learning, wisdom, and use."
The Great Audit, or, Good Steward: being some necessary and important considerations, to be considered of by all sorts of people / taken out of the writings of the late worthy and renowned Sir Matthew Hale, and therein, his own experience, of the inward and invisible guidance of the spirit of God. Newport, R.I.: Printed at the office of the Newport Mercury, 1805. 29 pp.
The Great Audit, or, Good Steward. Philadelphia: To be had of Benjamin & Thomas Kite, Joseph R.A. Skerrett). Pennsylvania; Philadelphia, 1816. 12 pp.
By one who thinks with that eminent judge, Sir Matthew Hale, that religion is the first concern of man. Address to the Deists: or, an inquiry into the character of the author of the book of Revelation. The second edition with additions. London, 1792. 143pp.
The Sum of Religion. Written by Judge Hale, Lord Chief Justice of England, and was found in the closet, amongst his other papers after his decease. [London], 1796. 1pp.
Contemplations moral and divine: in two parts. London, 1711. 580 pp.
"All those that truly fear God, have a sincere Guidance from a higher Wisdom than what is barely human, namely, The Spirit of Truth and Wisdom, that doth really and truly, but secretly prevent and direct them. Any Man that sincerely and truly fears Almighty God relies upon him, and calls upon him for His Guidance and Direction, hath it as really as a Son hath the Counsel and Direction of a Father, and tho' the Voice be not audible, nor the Direction always perceptible, or discernable to Sense, yet it is equally as real as if a Man heard the Voice, saying, This is the Way, walk in it. And this secret Direction of the Almighty God is principally seen in Matters relating to the good of the Soul, yet it may also be found in the concerns of this Life, which a good man, that fears God, and begs his direction, shall very often, if not at all times, find." p. 45.
"I can call my own experience to witness, That even in the external Actions of my whole Life, I was never disappointed of the best Guidance and Direction, when I have, in humility & sincerity, implored the secret Direction and Guidance of the divine Wisdom." p. 323.
Some Necessary and Important Considerations directed to all sorts of people . Taken out of the writings of that late worthy and renowned judge Sir Matthew Hales [sic]; Wherein is discovered his own experience of the inward and invisible guidance of the Spirit of God Edition: The tenth edition. [Four lines from Psalms] [New York]: Printed and sold by William Bradford in New-York, 1736. 24 pp.
Some Necessary and important considerations, directed to all sorts of people, taken out of the writings of that late worthy and renowned judge Sir Matthew Hale; Wherein is discovered, his own experience of the inward and invisible guidance of the Spirit of God Edition: Twelfth edition. [Three lines from Psalms]. Woodbridge [N.J.]: Printed and sold, by James Parker, 1759. 16 pp.; 19 cm
A New analysis of chronology: in which an attempt is made to explain the history and antiquities of the primitive nations of the world, and the prophecies relating to them ... / by William Hales. 2nd ed., corr. and improved. Volume 1 of 4. Volume 2 of 4. Volume 3 of 4. Volume 4 of 4. London: Printed for C.J.G. & F. Rivington, 1830. 4 v. : ill. ; 22 cm.
Memoirs of the life of the Reverend, learned and pious Mr. Thomas Halyburton... In four parts. Whereof three were drawn up by himself, the fourth collected by his friends ... The eight [sic] edition. With a large recommendatory epistle by I. Watts. Glasgow: printed by Archibald M'Lean, for John Orr,1756. xi,[13], 272 pp.
A Narrative of the life of Mrs. Hamilton. The following is a true account of the dealings of God with the widow Sarah Hamilton, who was born and educated in the Romish religion, and afterwards converted to the Christian faith, as will appear in this narrative. Boston: Printed and sold by E. Lincoln, 1806. 12 pp.; 17 cm.
A Second Defence of the learned Hugo Grotius; or, A vindication of the digression concerning him from some fresh exceptions. London: Printed by J. Flesher, for Richard Royston, 1655. 17 pp. Harvard University Library. Also here
Hancock, John
(1737-1793)
Governor of Massachusetts. American Founding Founder. Read about Hancock here.
WORKS
Commonwealth of Massachusetts. A Proclamation for a Day of Public Thanksgiving, November 27, 1788. Proclamation dated October 29, 1788.
"In circumstances as dark as these, it becomes us, as Men and Christians, to reflect that whilst every prudent measure should be taken to ward off the impending judgments, --at the same time all confidence must be withheld from the means we use; and reposed only on that God rules in the armies of Heaven, and without His whole blessing, the best human counsels are but foolishness? Resolved; --Thursday the 11th of May--to humble themselves before God under the heavy judgments felt and feared, to confess the sins that have deserved them, to implore the Forgiveness of all our transgressions, and a spirit of repentance and reformation --and a Blessing on the Union of the American Colonies in Defense of their Rights [for which hitherto we desire to thank Almighty God]--That the people of Great Britain and their rulers may have their eyes opened to discern the things that shall make for the peace of the nation--for the redress of America's many grievances, the restoration of all her invaded liberties, and their security to the latest generations."
Commonwealth of Massachusetts. A Proclamation for a Day of Public Thanksgiving, November 17, 1791. Proclamation dated October 5, 1791. Printed at Boston: By Thomas Adams, printer to the honorable General Court of the commonwealth of Massachusetts, 1791. 1 sheet, 1 p.: ill. (relief cut); 51 x 40 cm.
An Essay on the Unreasonableness of Scepticism. Oxford: University Press, 1801. 302 pp.; 17 cm. OCLC: 28532309.
"In a conversation which passed between a gentleman (formerly one of his parishioners) and the writer of this essay, on the subject of Revealed Religion, the former spake of it in the most irreverend manner, and said, that, before he should believe in it, it must be proved to him, that the philosophy and theological knowledge possessed by the heathens, (much greater than it was in general allowed to be) was so defective, as to render a particular revelation necessary.
"Secondly, he laid, that he confidered it derogatory to the dignity and majesty of the Deity, to make any such particular revelation; which he considered likewise unnecessary, because God governed the moral as well as natural world by general laws, and had endued man with reason and conscience, which were sufficient for his conduct in life; and that, if there had been any such revelation, it would have been univerfal, and not confined to so small a part of the globe, that the major part of its inhabitants have never even heard of the Chriftian religion. Farther, it does not appear, (he said) in those nations which profess Christianity, that its doctrines have produced that material or beneficial effect, either on the opinions or manners of the inhabitants, which a Revelation proceeding from God would produce.
"Thirdly, he said, before he should give any credit to it, he must be satisfied that what is called Scripture and the word of God, was not forged, to anlwer the sinister views and purpofes of man.
"Fourthly, that he did not believe sufficient evidence of the truth of Revealed Religion could be adduced, to satisfy the mind of a man, whose reason was unimpaired, and whose understanding was improved and cultivated.
" A particular refutation of each of thefe objections is, in this Essay, attempted; and in the hope to remove them from the mind of this gentleman, and others, it is published." Review in The Anti-Jacobin Review and Magazine, n. 47, May 1802. "We do not recommend this volume to the perusal of Sceptics only; for even to those who possess a firm confidence in the Sublime doctrines of Christianity, it may Serve as a lively remembrancer of many valuable points in their belief."
Harmer, Thomas
(1714-1788)
WORKS
Observations on Various Passages of Scripture: placing them in a new light and ascertaining the meaning of several not determinable by the methods commonly made use of by the learned. Originally compiled by the Rev. Thomas Harmer, from relations incidentally mentioned in books of voyages and travels into the East. London: Lackington and W. Baynes, 1816. Vol 1, Vol 2, Vol 3 and Vol 4.
Harnack, Adolf
(1851-1930)
Historian and theologian. Disclaimer: Harnack had some "liberal" tendencies, but he often defended orthodox points of view as well. Read about Harnack here.
[Die Mission und Ausbreitung des Christentums in den ersten drei Jahrhunderten -- English]. James Moffatt, translator and editor. Mission and Expansion of Christianity in the First Three Centuries.Gloucester, Mass., Peter Smith, 1972
xix, 527 pp. illus. 21 cm. This is Volume One of the Second, enlarged and revised edition published in England in 1904. London: Williams & Norgate. The first edition appeared under title: The Expansion of Christianity.
Introductory. Judaism: its diffusion and limits; The external conditions of the world-wide expansion of the Christian religion; The internal conditions determining the world-wide expansion of the Christian religion: religious syncretism; Jesus Christ and the universal mission; The transition from the Jewish to the Gentile mission; Results of the mission of Paul and of the first missionaries -- Mission-preaching in word and deed. The religious characteristics of the mission-preaching; The gospel of the Saviour and of salvation; The conflict with demons; The gospel of love and charity; The religion of the Spirit and of power, of moral earnestness and holiness; The religion of authority and of reason, of the mysteries and of transcendentalism; The tidings of the new people and of the third race: the historical and political consciousness of Christendom; The religion of a book and a historical realization; The conflict with polytheism and idolatry -- The missionaries: the methods of the mission and the counter-movements. The Christian missionaries (apostles, evangelists, and prophets or teachers: the informal missionaries) ; Methods of the mission: catechizing and baptism, the invasion of domestic life; The names of Christian believers; The organisation of the Christian community, as bearing upon the Christian mission; Counter-movements.
[Neue Untersuchungen zur Apostelgeschichte und zur Abfassungszeit der synoptischen Evangelien -- English] New Testament studies. IV. Date of the Acts and Synoptic Gospels. London: Williams & Norgate; New York: G.P. Putnam's Sons, 1911. 162 pp.; 19 cm. Translated by John Richard Wilkinson.
Harness, William
(1790-1869)
WORKS
The Connexion of Christianity with human happiness: being the substance of the Boyle lectures for the year 1821. London: John Murray, 1823. 2 volumes; 19 cm. Volume 1 of 2, 290 pp. Volume 2 of 2, 348 pp.
Review here.
Harris, Frederick Brown
(1883-1970)
Clergyman.
WORKS
To Preachers on being "Allowed of God to be put in trust with the Gospel," by Dr. Frederick Brown Harris. A message based on the Yale lectures on preaching by Dr. Paul Scherer. Presented by Mr. Donnell. June 8 (legislative day, March 5), 1946. -- Ordered to be printed. Serial Set Vol. No. 11037 Session Vol. No. 11. 79th Congress, 2nd Session. S.Doc. 202. Washington G.P.O., June 8, 1946. 17 pp.
The Kingdom of Christ on Earth: Twelve lectures delivered before the students of the Theological Seminary, Andover.
New Englander and Yale review, Volume 34, Issue 131, April 1875. pp. 375-377. New Haven: W. L. Kingsley etc. 810 page images in vol.
Harrison, John
(fl. 1610-1638)
WORKS
The Messiah alreadie come. Or Proofs of Christianitie both out of the Scriptures, and auncient rabbins, to convince the Iewes, of their palpable, and more then miserable blindnes (if more may be) for their long, vayne, and endles expectation of their Messiah (as they dreame) yet for to come. Written in Barbarie, in the yeare 1610, & for that cause directed to the dispersed Iewes of that countrie, & in them to all others now groaning under the yoake of this their long & intollerable captivitie: which yet one day shall have an end. 2nd edition. Amsterdam: Imprinted by Giles Thorp, Anno M. 1613. [12], 68 pp. Folger Shakespeare Library.
Observations on Man, his frame, his duty, and his expectations. In two parts. London, 1791. Volume 1 of 3, 531 pp., Volume 2, 469 pp., Volume 3, 351 pp. Vol. 3 has title: 'Notes and additions to Dr. Hartley's Observations on man', London, printed for J. Johnson, 1791./ Vols. 2-3 have continuous pagination./ Reproduction of original from the Harvard University Libraries. This work was recommended by Joseph Priestley to Benjamin Franklin. (Priestley, Joseph. Memoirs of Dr. Joseph Priestley to the year 1795. Volume 1, page 99. London, 1825. 499 pp. 2 vols.)
Letters on the American war. Addressed to the Right Worshipful the Mayor and Corporation, of the town of Kingston-upon-Hull. The seventh edition. London, 1779. 131pp.
A New Introduction to the study and knowledge of the New Testament. Volume 1 of 2. Volume 2 of 2. The 2nd edition, corrected and enlarged. London: Printed for T. Becket ..., 1773. 2 vol.; 22 cm. 1767 edition. Printed for T. Becket and P. A. de Hondt; and J. Johnson and B. Davenport, 1767. 360 pp.
Herbert Marsh, A Course of Lectures, containing a description and systematic arrangement of the several branches of divinity accompanied with an account of the progress, which has been made at different periods in theological learning by Herbert Marsh, 1812: "Dr. Harwood's Introduction to the Study and Knowledge of the New Testament, of which the first volume was published in 1767, the second in 1771, I mention at present more on account of its title, than on account of its contents. Though entitled An Introduction to the New Testament, it is not so in the sense, in which the abovementioned works are Introductions. It does not describe the several books of the New Testament, but contains a collection of dissertations, relative partly to the characters of the Sacred Writers, partly to the Jewish history and customs, and to such parts of heathen antiquities, as have reference to the New Testament. But, as these dissertations display great erudition, and contain much information illustrative of the New Testament, Dr. Harwood's Introduction is certainly to be recommended to the theological student."
Christian Patriotism; A Medium of God's power and purpose to bless our land: A Sermon, delivered in the First Presbyterian Church, East Boston, at the united service, national fast day, April 30, 1863. Boston: Hollis & Gunn, Printers, 1863. 40 pp.; 23 cm.
A Dissertation upon the use and importance of unauthoritative tradition, as an introduction to the Christian doctrines; including the substance of a sermon, preached before the University of Oxford, May 31, 1818. London: Society for Promoting Christian Knowledge; New York: E. & J.B. Young, 1889. xii, 65, 49 pp.; 19 cm. Also here.
WHILST the subject of Scriptural difficulties has been often admirably handled both generally and in detail, there is still one arising from the very form and structure of the Scriptures, on which sufficient attention has not perhaps been bestowed; although it is a source of sensible uneasiness to some believers, and secretly influences the practice of many more. The purpose of the following pages is to state and consider this difficulty; and further, to pursue into some of its more important particulars the view,
which that inquiry suggests, of the value of unauthoritative tradition, not so much in the confirmation or interpretation of Christian doctrines, but as
intended to be the ordinary introduction to them.
... If these few pages can in the slightest degree contribute to such valuable ends, and if they are capable also incidentally of supplying a ready answer to certain popular objections, either against the evidence of some important articles of faith, or even against revealed religion itself, they will have been without impropriety offered to the publick at large. To the candid consideration of the Established Clergy they are submitted in a more especial manner, but with peculiar deference; they are addressed however to every thoughtful believer in Christianity, and to those also who have not yet admitted the claims of Eevelation, but who are honestly intent upon the discovery of religious truth.
With George Miller. An Historical view of the plea of tradition, as maintained in the Church of Rome with strictures on a dissertation upon the use and importance of unauthoritative tradition by Edward Hawkins ... and an appendix containing original authorities. London: C. and J. Rivington; Dublin : R. Milliken, 1826. 102 pp.; 20 cm.
U.S. District Attorney for Montana. Editorial writer. Educator. Conservationist.
Bio/History: Cornelius Hedges was born on 28 Oct. 1831 in Westfield, Mass., the son of Dennis and Alvina Hedges. He attended Yale College, receiving an A.B. in 1853 and an A.M. in 1855. He also attended Harvard Law School and was admitted to the Massachusetts bar. He married Edna Smith in 1856 and the couple moved to Independence, Iowa, where Hedges practiced law and published the Independence Civilian. Hedges traveled to Virginia City, Montana Territory, in 1864 to placer mine. The following year he moved to Helena where he mined, practiced law, and was a public servant. In 1870 Hedges joined the Washburn Expedition which explored and publicized the Yellowstone area. Following the trip, it was Hedges who suggested the preservation of the area as a national park and he was active in this movement. In 1903 he was an honored guest at the cornerstone laying ceremony for the arch at the park entrance. Cornelius Hedges died in Helena on 29 Apr. 1907.
Read more about Hedges here and here. Disclaimer: Hedges was a Freemason.
WORKS
1864-1865. Diary and reminiscences. From the Montana Historical Society Archives. Abstract:
Diary, in two parts, and reminiscences. The first part of the diary includes daily entries from 20 Apr. to 12 July 1864. It begins with Hedges leaving Iowa for Idaho. This part of the diary covers his daily experiences on the westward journey. The second part of the diary describes his experiences working in the gold mines upon his arrival in Virginia City in July 1864. This part of the diary includes daily entries from 12 July to 31 Dec. 1864. He mostly writes of his daily work of mining, the cold, and business deals. This section also includes a record of cash accounts from July to Sept. The third manuscript in this collection consists of excerpts from his manuscript entitled "Reminiscences of Early Days in Helena". This covers his experiences just after leaving Virginia City for the mining prospects at Helena's Last Chance Gulch in Jan. 1865.
Christian Virtue, the Only Sure Basis of Civil Liberty. Spoken at Commencement at Yale College July 28, 1853. From the Montana Historical Society Archives.
The essence of civil liberty is self-government. This principle divides the race into slaves and freemen and according as it is recognized or not, a government is free or despotic.
There are two vital principals [sic] in human government. The first is that there is a God, the sovereign of the universe, who has given law to man. The second is that man is God's deputy-governor over himself-Thus from the first was the government of our race disposed. So says revelation and all human history rightly interprets as a commentary upon it.
Montana Historical Society. Contributions to the Historical Society of Montana with its transactions, act of incorporation, constitution, ordinances, officers and members. Helena, Mont. Part 1, Part 2. Volume 7. Helena, Mont.: Rocky Mountain Pub. Co., 1876-1910. 374 pp. 9 vols. Extract.
Christology of the Old Testament, and a Commentary on the Predictions of the Messiah by the Prophets Volume 1. 1836.
Christology of the Old Testament, and a Commentary on the Predictions of the Messiah by the Prophets Vol 2. 1839.
Christology of the Old Testament, and a Commentary on the Predictions of the Messiah by the Prophets Vol 2.
Henry, Carl
(1913-2003)
Biblical commentator.
WORKS
Jesus of Nazareth Saviour and Lord. Cross-currents in contemporary theology / Carl F. H. Henry -- The new quest of the historical Jesus / Ralph P. Martin -- The authenticity and authority of revelation / Birger Gerhardsson -- Jesus Christ, the center of history / Adolf Köberle -- The last days in the Bible and Qumran / R. Laird Harris -- History and the Gospel / F.F. Bruce -- The teaching of Jesus and the Gospel records / Bastiaan Van Elderen -- The fourth Gospel and history / Leon Morris -- The historicity of the resurrection / Merrill C. Tenney -- "On the third day" / Clark H. Pinnock -- Gemeindetheologie: the bane of Gospel criticism / Everett F. Harrison -- Faith as historical understanding / James P. Martin -- Fact and faith in the kerygma / Paul Althaus -- Bultmann's historiography / Gordon H. Clark -- Toward a Christian philosophy of history / John Warwick Montgomery -- The Christ-revelation as act and interpretation / Kenneth S. Kantzer. Grand Rapids, Eerdmans 1966. viii, 277 pp. 24 cm. Buy this book here.
Henry, Matthew
(1662-1714)
Biblical commentator. Read about Henry here and here.
WORKS
Matthew Henry's
Commentary on the Whole Bible. CCEL: "This work was long celebrated as the best English commentary for devotional purposes and the expanded edition was initially published in 1896. Instead of critical exposition, Henry focuses on practical suggestion, and his commentaries contains rich stores of truths."
With George Burder; Joseph Hughes; Samuel Palmer; Edward Leslie Conn. An Exposition of the Old and New Testament; wherein each chapter is summed up in its contents, the sacred text inserted at large, in distinct paragraphs: each paragraph reduced to its proper heads: the sense given, and largely illustrated with practical remarks and observations. Volume 1. v. 1. Genesis-Deuteronomy. Volume 2. v. 2. Joshua-Esther. Volume 3. v. 3. Job-Solomon's song. Volume 4. v. 4. Isaiah-Malachi. Volume 5. v. 5. St. Matthew-St. John. Volume 6. v. 6. Acts-Revelation. Edited by George Burder and Joseph Hughes; with the life of the author by Samuel Palmer. Philadelphia: Ed. Barrington & Geo. D. Haswell, 1828. Text-searchable.
Speech delivered July 4, 1776.. Includes footnote on the history of the Liberty Bell, inscribed with the verse from Leviticus 15:10.
Samuel Greene Arnold. The Life of Patrick Henry of Virginia. Auburn [N.Y.]: Miller, Orton and Mulligan, 1854, [c1845]. 269 pp. Henry's letter to his daughter Betsy on August 20, 1796, p. 250.
Samuel Greene Arnold. The Life of Patrick Henry of Virginia. Auburn [N.Y.]: Miller, Orton and Mulligan, 1854, [c1845]. 269 pp. Henry's letter to his daughter Betsy on August 20, 1796, p. 250. Also here.
"The view which the rising greatness of our country presents to my eyes, is greatly tarnished by the general prevalence of deism, which, with me, is but another name for vice and depravity. I am, however, much consoled by reflecting that the religion of Christ has, from its first appearance in the world been attacked in vain by all the wits, philosophers and wise ones, aided by every power of man, and its triumph has been complete. What is there in the wit or wisdom of the present deistical writers or professors that can compare them with Hume, Shaftsbury, Bolingbroke and others; and yet these have been confuted, and their fame is decaying, insomuch that at the puny efforts of Paine are thrown in to prop their tottering fabric, whose foundations cannot stand the test of time.
"Among other strange things said of me, I hear it is said by the deists that I am one of their number; and, indeed, that some good people think I am no Christian. This thought gives me much more pain than the appellation of tory, because I think religion of infinitely higher importance than politics, and I find much cause to reproach myself that I have lived so long and have given no decided and public proofs of my being a Christian. But, indeed, my dear child, this is a character which I prize far above all this world has, or can boast. And among all the handsome things I hear said of you, what gives me the greatest pleasure is, to be told of your piety and steady virtue. Be assured there is not one tittle, as to disposition or character, in which my parental affection for you would suffer a wish for your changing, and it flatters my pride to have you spoken of as you are.
"Perhaps Mr. Roane and Anne may have heard (he reports you mention. If it will be any object with them to see what I write you, show them this. But my wish is to pass the rest of my days, as much as may be, unobserved by the critics of the world, who would show but little sympathy for the deficiencies to which old age is liable. May God bless you, my dear Betsy, and your children."
George Morgan. The True Patrick Henry: With Twenty-four Illustrations. Lippincott, 1907. 492 pages. Original from the New York Public Library.
* In William Meade's "Old Churches, Ministers, and Families of Virginia," vol. ii, p. 12, the Rev. Mr. Dresser says that Patrick Henry had " a very great abhorrence of infidelity, and actually wrote a reply to 'Paine's Age of Reason,' but destroyed it before his death." "This," comments Edward Fontaine, "is certainly true. My father, Colonel Patrick H. Fontaine, was the oldest grandson of Patrick Henry. He was living with his grandfather when he wrote the reply to Paine mentioned by Mr. Dresser." But Patrick Henry, having read Bishop Watson's "Apology for the Bible," and deeming it a sufficient answer to Paine, decided not to publish his own manuscript."--p. 366 n.
George Morgan. The True Patrick Henry: With Twenty-four Illustrations. Lippincott, 1907. 492 pages. Original from the New York Public Library.
"Judge Winston tells us that Henry travelled about "on a circuit (Nelson and White, Judges) carrying Soame Jenyns, of which he gave the Judges a copy, desiring them at the same time not to take him for a travelling monk." This book, which bears the title, "Internal Evidences of Christianity," was printed and given free circulation in Virginia at Henry's own expense. Howe says that Henry did the same with Butler's "Analogy," adding: "Sherlock's Sermons, he affirmed, was the work which removed all his doubts of the truth of Christianity; a copy of which, until a short time since, was filled with marginal notes. He read it every Sunday evening to his family, after which they all joined in sacred music, while he accompanied them on the violin. He never quoted poetry. His quotations were from the Bible, and his illustrations from the Bible and ancient and modern history." *
"But we have taken him away from his family and started him in his gig towards the court-houses; and we shall go on in that direction after inviting attention to an important fact: Henry was almost a born believer, as well as a born Whig. He got his religion and his politics out of nature in the first place, and in the next place out of that part of the Bible which teaches kindness to all men. Milton, Locke, Sidney, and other great forebears of freedom had intellectualized the grand political idea; but it came to Henry, as it did to other men of his day, by the working of his own mind."
* In William Meade's "Old Churches, Ministers, and Families of Virginia," vol. ii, p. 12, the Rev. Mr. Dresser says that Patrick Henry had "a very great abhorrence of infidelity, and actually wrote a reply to 'Paine's Age of Reason,' but destroyed it before his death." "This," comments Edward Fontaine, "is certainly true. My father, Colonel Patrick H. Fontaine, was the oldest grandson of Patrick Henry. He was living with his grandfather when he wrote the reply to Paine mentioned by Mr. Dresser." But Patrick Henry, having read Bishop Watson's "Apology for the Bible," and deeming it a sufficient answer to Paine, decided not to publish his own manuscript."--p. 366 n.
Herald of Gospel Liberty
(1808-1930)
Dayton, Ohio [etc.] Christian Pub. Association. 122 volumes. Founded and for some years edited by Elias Smith. Official organ of the Christian Church, -Feb. 27, 1930.
Absorbed: Christian missionary, and: Journal of Christian education, Jan. 5, 1928. Their contents are continued in the magazine number of the Herald of gospel liberty which appears as the first weekly issue of the month./ Merged with: Congregationalist (Boston, Mass.: 1921), to form: Congregationalist and herald of gospel liberty.
Four Sermons on the divinity of Christ
by the late Rev. James Hervey, To which are added, four other sermons, faithfully transcribed from the original short-hand of the author. London: printed for the editor, and sold by G. Keith; T. Vallance; J. Mathews, and W. Otridge, 1779. xvi, 92 pp.
Theron and Aspasio: or, A Series of dialogues and letters, upon the most important and interesting subjects. In three volumes. London: printed by Charles Rivington, for John and James Rivington, 1755. Volume 1 of 3. Volume 2 of 3. Volume 3 of 3.
The Cause of God and his people in New-England: as it was stated and discussed in a sermon preached before the Honourable General Court of the ... Cambridg [sic, i.e., Cambridge, Mass.], 1663. 27 pp.
The Elements of Law, Natural and Politic, edited with a preface and critical notes by Ferdinand Tönnies, to which are subjoined selected extracts from unprinted mss. of Thomas Hobbes. London, 1889. 240 pp. "10. And seeing our faith, that the Scriptures are the word of
God, began from the confidence and trust we repose in the church;
there can be no doubt but that their interpretation of the same
Scriptures, when any doubt or controversy shall arise, by which
this fundamental point, that Jesus Christ is come in the flesh,
is not called in question, is safer for any man to trust to, than
his own, whether reasoning, or spirit; that is to say his own
opinion."
Hodge, A. A.
(1823-1886)
Presbyterian leader.
WORKS
The Inspiration of the Bible. "That the sacred writers were so influenced by the Holy spirit that their writings are, as a whole and in every part, God's word to us--an authoritative revelation to us from God, endorsed by him, and sent to us as a rule of faith and practice, the original autographs of which are absolutely infallible when interpreted in the sense intended, and hence are clothed with absolute divine authority."
The Rule Of Faith And Practice. "The Scriptures of the Old and New Testaments, having been given by inspiration of God, are the all-sufficient and only rule of faith and practice, and judge of controversies."
Hodge, Charles
(1797-1878)
Leader, Princeton Theological Seminary. Read more about Hodge here and here.
A Course of legal study: addressed to students and the profession generally. 2nd edition, rewritten and much enlarged. Vol. 1. Baltimore, 1836. 2 vols. Volume 1 and Volume 2.
A Circular to students at law in the United States. Baltimore, 1844. 12pp. In this circular, Hoffman is recommended by Supreme Court Justice Joseph Story, The Philadelphia Inquirer, The Baltimore Patriot, The Philadelphia Daily Sun, and The Philadelphia United States Gazette.
The Impossible Faith. Offers 17 reasons why Christianity could not have survived in the ancient world unless it had indisputable evidence of the resurrection of Jesus. Buy the expanded book version here.
Answering Copycat Charges. Articles on alleged "copycat" saviors (Mithra, Dionysus, Attis, etc). Pick your "heresy of the week"!
Biblical vs. Japanese Culture. A comparison. The culture of the Bible was more like Japan's than ours, which affects how we read the Bible.
Self Center. Some thoughts on so-called "self-esteem" and how the ancient mindset on "self" is reflected in the Bible, and provides us an answer for today.
Faith vs Works. How are we saved? Which saves us? Three words: Semitic Totality Concept.
Integrity and Religion to be Principally Regarded By Such as Design Others to Stations of Publick Trust: A sermon preach'd before His Excellency, Jonathan Belcher, Esq; His Majesty's Council, and the Assembly of the province of the Massachusetts-Bay in New-England, on the anniversary for the election of counsellors for said province, May 26. 1736. Boston: Printed by J. Draper, printer to His Excellency the Governour and Council, for J. Eliot, 1736. 55 pp. "The man of true integrity acts always under a sense of his duty to God."
The Works of that learned and judicious divine Mr. Richard Hooker, containing eight books of The laws of ecclesiastical polity, and several other treatises. To which is prefixed the life of the author, by Isaac Walton. To this edition is subjoined a new index to the whole. Oxford, MDCCXCIII. [1793]. Volume 1 of 3. 507 pp. Volume 2 of 3. Volume 3 of 3.
The Laws of Ecclesiastical polity. G. Routledge, 1888. 288 pp.
Laws for the Church are not made as they should be unless the makers follow such direction as they ought to be guided by. Wherein that Scripture standeth not the Church of God in any stead, or serveth nothing at all to direct, but may be let pass as needless to be consulted with, we judge it profane, impious, and irreligious to think. For although it were in vain to make laws which the Scripture hath already made, because what we are already there commanded to do on our parts there resteth nothing but only that it be executed; yet because both in that which we are commanded, it concerneth the duty of the Church by law to provide that the looseness and slackness of men may not cause the commandments of God to be unexecuted, and a number of things there are for which the Scripture hath not provided by any law, but left them unto the careful discretion of the Church; we are to search how the Church in these cases may be well directed to make that provision by laws which' is most convenient and fit. And what is so in these cases, partly Scripture and partly reason must teach to discern. Scripture comprehending examples and laws, laws some natural and some positive, examples neither are there for all cases which require laws to be made, and when they are they can but direct as precedents only. Natural laws direct in such sort that in all things we must for ever do according unto them; positive, so that against them in no case we may do anything, as long as the will of God is that they should remain in force. Howbeit, when Scripture doth yield us precedents, how far forth they are to be followed; when it giveth natural laws, what particular order is thereunto most agreeable; when positive, which way to make laws unrepugnant unto them; yea, though all these should want yet what kind of ordinances would be most for that good of the Church which is aimed at, all this must be by reason found out. And, therefore, "To refuse the conduct of the light of Nature," saith St. Augustine, "is not folly alone, but accompanied with impiety." The greatest amongst the school divines, studying how to set down by exact definition the nature of a human law (of which nature all the Church's constitutions are), found not which way better to do it than in these words, " Out of the precepts of the law of Nature, as out of certain common and undemonstrable principles, man's reason doth necessarily proceed unto certain more particular determinations, which particular determinations being found out according unto the reason of man, they have the names of human laws, so that such other conditions be therein kept as the making of laws doth require," that is, if they whose authority is thereunto required do establish and publish them as laws. And the truth is that all our controversy in this cause concerning the orders of the Church is, what particulars the Church may appoint. That which doth find them out is the force of man's reason. That which doth guide and direct his reason is, first, the general law of Nature, which law of Nature and the moral law of Scripture are in the substance of law all one. But because there are also in Scripture a number of laws particular and positive, which being in force may not by any law of man be violated, we are in making laws to have thereunto an especial eye. As for example, it might perhaps seem reasonable unto the Church of God, following the general laws concerning the nature of marriage, to ordain in particular that cousins-german shall not marry. Which law notwithstanding ought not to be received in the Church if there should be in the Scripture a law particular to the contrary, forbidding utterly the bonds of marriage to be so far forth abridged. The same Thomas, therefore, whose definition of human laws we mentioned before, doth add thereunto this caution concerning the rule and canon whereby to make them: "Human laws are measures in respect of men whose actions they must direct, howbeit such measures they are, as have also their higher rules to be measured by, which rules are two, the law of God and the law of Nature. So that laws human must be made according to the general laws of Nature, and without contradiction unto any positive law in Scripture, otherwise they are ill made. Unto laws thus made and received by a whole Church, they which live within the bosom of that Church must not think it a matter indifferent either to yield or not to yield obedience, Is it a small offence to despise the Church of God? "My son, keep thy father's commandment," saith Solomon, "and forget not thy mother's instruction, bind them both always about thine heart." It doth not stand with the duty which we owe to our heavenly Father, that to the ordinances of our Mother the Church we should show ourselves disobedient. Let us not say we keep the commandments of the one, when we break the law of the other, for unless we observe both we obey neither. And what doth let, but that we may observe both, when they are not the one to the other in any sort repugnant? For of such laws only we speak, as being made in form and manner already declared, can have in them no contradiction unto the laws of Almighty God. Yea, that which is more, the laws thus made God himself doth in such sort authorize, that to despise them is to despise in them Him. It is a loose and licentious opinion which the Anabaptists have embraced, holding that a Christian man's liberty is lost, and the soul which Christ hath redeemed unto Himself injuriously drawn into servitude under the yoke of human power, if any law be now imposed besides the Gospel of Jesus Christ, in obedience whereunto the Spirit of God, and not the constraint of men, is to lead us, according to that of the blessed Apostle, "Such as are led by the Spirit of God are the sons of God," and not such as live in thraldom unto men.
Their judgment is, therefore, that the Church of Christ should admit no law-makers but the Evangelists. The author of that which causeth another thing to be, is author of that thing also which thereby is caused. The light of natural understanding, wit, and reason, is from God; He it is which thereby doth illuminate every man entering into the world. If there proceed from us anything afterwards corrupt and naught, the mother thereof is our own darkness, neither doth it proceed from any such cause whereof God is the author. He is the author all that we think or do by virtue of that light which Himself hath given. And therefore the laws which the very heathens did gather to direct their actions by, so far forth as they proceeded from the light of Nature, God himself doth acknowledge to have proceeded even from Himself, and that He was the writer of them in the tables of their hearts. How much more, then, is He the author of those laws which have been made by His saints, endued further with the heavenly grace of His Spirit, and directed as much as might be with such instructions as His sacred word doth yield? Surely if we have unto those laws that dutiful regard which their dignity doth require, it will not greatly need that we should be exhorted to live in obedience unto them. If they have God himself for their author, contempt which is offered unto them cannot choose but redound unto Him.
Application of Redemption, by the effectual work of the word, and spirit of Christ, for the bringing home of lost sinners to God. Parts 9-10. Besides many other seasonable, and soul-searching truths, there is also largely shewed, I. The heart must be humble and contrite before the Lord will dwell in it. ... 10. Gross and scandalous sinners, God usually exerciseth with heavy breakings of heart, before they be brought to Christ. 11. Sorrow for sin rightly set on, pierceth the heart of the sinner throughly. ... 18. The soul that is pierced for sin, is carried with a restless dislike against it. By that faithful, and known servant of Christ, Mr. Thomas Hooker, late pastor of the church at Hartford in New-England; somtimes preacher of the Word at Chelmsford in Essex, and fellow of Emmanuel Colledg in Cambridg. Printed from the authors papers, written with his own hand. And attested to be such, in an epistle, by Thomas Goodwin, and Philip Nye. London: printed by Peter Cole, at the sign of the Printing-Press in Cornhil, neer the Royal Exchange, 1657. [24], 455, 556-702, [30] pp.
Three Sermons. I. The wrath of God against sinners, II. God's eternitie, and mans humanitie, III. The plantation of the righteous. London: Printed by M.P. for Iohn Stafford, dwelling in Black-Horse-Alley neere Fleetstreet, 1638. [2], 139 pp.
Foure learned and godly treatises. The carnall hypocrite. The churches deliverances. The deceitfulnesse of sinne. The benefit of afflictions. London: By Tho. Cotes, for Andrew Crooke, and are to be sold at the signe of the Beare in Pauls Churchyard, 1638. [4], 293, [1] pp.
Hoover, President Herbert
(1874-1964)
American President. Read more about President Hoover here and here.
WORKS
Message to the National Federation of Men's Bible Classes, May 5th, 1929. "THERE IS no other book so various as the Bible, nor one so full of concentrated wisdom. Whether it be of law, business, morals, or that vision which leads the imagination in the creation of constructive enterprises for the happiness of mankind, he who seeks for guidance in any of these things may look inside its covers and find illumination. The study of this Book in your Bible classes is a postgraduate course in the richest library of human experience....As a nation we are indebted to the Book of Books for our national ideals and representative institutions. Their preservation rests in adhering to its principles."
Radio Address to the Nation on Unemployment Relief, October 18, 1931. Also here.
"Our country and the world are today involved in more than a financial crisis. We are faced with the primary question of human relations, which reaches to the very depth of organized society and to the very depth of human conscience. This civilization and this great complex, which we call American life, is builded and can alone survive upon the translation into individual action of the fundamental philosophy announced by the Savior nineteen centuries ago. Part of our national suffering today is from failure to observe these primary yet inexorable laws of human relationship. Modern society can not survive with the defense of Cain, ?Am I my brother's keeper??
"No governmental action, no economic doctrine, no economic plan or project can replace that God-imposed responsibility of the individual man and woman to their neighbors. That is a vital part of the very soul of the people. If we shall gain in this spirit from this painful time, we shall have created a greater and more glorious America. The trial of it is here now. It is a trial of the heart and conscience, of individual men and women."
An Inquiry concering [sic] the future state of those who die in their sins: Wherein the dictates of Scripture and reason, upon this important subject, are carefully considered; and whether endless punishment be consistent with divine justice, wisdom and goodness: in which also objections are stated and answered. By Samuel Hopkins, A.M. Pastor of the First Congregational Church in Newport. [Two lines of Scripture text]. Newport, Rhode-Island: Printed by Solomon Southwick. 1783. [4], vi, 194 p. 19 cm. (4to)
A Discourse upon the Slave-trade, and the slavery of the Africans. Delivered in the Baptist meeting-house at Providence, before the Providence Society for Abolishing the Slave-Trade, &c. At their annual meeting, on May 17, 1793. Providence, Rhode Island; printed by J. Carter, 1793. 22, [6] pp.; 20 cm. (8vo)
Sketches of the Life of the Late, Rev. Samuel Hopkins, D. D., Pastor of the first Congregational Church in Newport, Written by Himself; Interspersed with Marginal Notes Extracted from his Private Diary; to which is added; A Dialogue, by the Same Hand, on the Nature and Extent of True Christian Submission; Also, A Serious Address to Professing Christians: Closed by Dr. Hart's Sermon at His Funeral: with an Introduction to the Whole, by the editor. Published by Stephen West, D. D., Pastor of the Church in Stockbridge. Hartford: Printed by Hudson and Goodwin, 1805. 240 pp.
Letters on Infidelity. The second edition. To which is prefixed a letter to Dr. Adam Smith. 2nd edition. Oxford, Clarendon Press, sold by D. Prince, 1786. 346 pp.
In the thirty sections of their pamphlet, they have produced a list of difficulties to be met with in reading the Old and New Testament. Had I been aware of their design, I could have enriched the collection with many more, at least as good, if not a little better. But they have compiled, I dare say, what they deemed the best, and, in their own opinion, presented us with the essence of infidelity in a thumb-phial, the very fumes of which, on drawing the cork, are to strike the bench of bishops dead at once.
Let not the unlearned Christian be alarmed, as though some strange thing had happened to him, and modern philosophy had discovered arguments to demolish religion, never heard of before. The old ornaments of deism have been broken off upon this occasion, and cast into the fire, and there came out this calf. These same difficulties have been again and again urged and discussed in public; again and again weighed and considered by learned and sensible men, of the laity as well as the clergy, who have by no means been induced by them to renounce their faith.
Indeed, why should they? For is any man surprised that difficulties should occur in the books of Scripture, those more particularly of the Old Testament? Let him reflect upon the variety of matter on which they treat; the distance of the times to which they refer; the wide difference of ancient manners and customs, from those of the age in which we live; the very imperfect knowledge we have of these, as well as of the language in which they are described; the conciseness of the narratives, sufficient for the purpose intended, but not for gratifying a restless curiosity; above all, the errors and defects of translations.
Many and painful are the researches sometimes necessary to be made, for settling points of that kind. Pertness and ignorance may ask a question in three lines, which it will cost learning and ingenuity thirty pages to answer. When this is done, the same question shall be triumphantly asked again the next year, as if nothing had ever been written upon the subject. And as people in general, for one reason or another, like short objections better than long answers, in this mode of disputation (if it can be styled such) the odds must ever be against us; and we must be content with those for our friends who have honesty and erudition, candor and patience, to study both sides of the question. Be it so. -- Letter 8.
The Duty of contending for the faith. A sermon preached at the visitation of the most reverend John Lord Archbishop of Canterbury, ... on Saturday, July 1, 1786. By George Horne, To which is subjoined a discourse on the trinity in unity. A new edition London, 1788. 52 pp.
Horne, Thomas Hartwell
(1780-1862)
(TM): Thomas Hartwell Horne (20 October, 1780 - 27 January, 1862) was an English theologian and librarian. In 1796 he became a barrister's clerk, but the salary was insufficient, so he turned to writing to make more money. Throughout his life Horne wrote more than forty works focused on Christian apologetics, and he edited and compiled even more works on a great variance of topics, from topography to Sunday schools. In 1818, after what he indicated was much prayer, solitude, and labor late at night, he released An Introduction to the Critical Study and Knowledge of the Holy Scriptures. It was to be Horne?s chief work and quickly became a favorite textbook in English-speaking Protestant colleges and universities. Due to the work's caliber, he was admitted to orders without the usual preliminaries, with King's College conferring upon him the honorary degree of MA.
Read more about Horne here and here.
An Introduction to the Critical Study and Knowledge of the Holy Scriptures, Volume 1, 1825 edition,
1841 edition,
1852 edition,
1877 edition. Edited by Thomas Hartwell Horne, John Ayre and Samuel Prideaux Tregelles. 14th edition, London: Longmans, Green, 1877.
Extract on alleged contradictions. Extract on the benefits of Christianity. Extract on collateral testimony.
Extract on the Preternatural Darkness at the Crucifixion:
Now from the sixth hour there was darkness over all the land until the ninth hour. ~ Matthew 27:45 ESV
One single example will illustrate the last three observations. The preternatural darkness of three hours, which prevailed in the land of Judaea at the time of Christ's crucifixion, and which has been recorded by three of the evangelists, is unnoticed by any profane historian; from which circumstance Mr. Gibbon took occasion to insinuate that the evidence of the evangelists is not sufficient to establish the truth of facts, unless it is supported by the concurrent testimony of pagan contemporary writers. Speaking of that darkness, he expresses his surprise that this miraculous event 'passed without notice in an age of science and history. It happened,'?he adds, 'during the lifetime of Seneca and the elder Pliny, who must have experienced the immediate effects, or received the earliest intelligence of the prodigy. Each of these philosophers, in a laborious work, has recorded all the great phenomena of nature, earthquakes, meteors, comets, and eclipses, which his indefatigable industry could collect. Both the one and the other have omitted to mention the greatest phenomenon to which mortal eye has been witness since the creation of the globe. A distinct chapter of Pliny is devoted to eclipses of an extraordinary nature and unusual duration: but he contents himself with describing the singular defect of light which followed the murder of Caesar, when, during the greatest part of the year, the orb of the sun appeared pale and without splendour.' [Decline and Fall, vol. ii, pp. 379.] The sentences printed in italic are those in which the sceptical historian has had recourse to those misrepresentations which unhappily pervade too many of his splendid pages. On this passage we remark,
FIRST, That the eclipse being confined to Judaea, its immediate effects could not necessarily have been experienced by Seneca or Pliny, neither of whom could have been on the spot in the reign of Tiberius, when the eclipse took place; nor can it be proved that they had immediate information from all parts of the globe as soon as any extraordinary phenomenon had taken place.
SECONDLY, Neither Pliny nor Seneca have left any works that correspond to the historian?s pompous description. Seneca does not treat on eclipses at all, in the passage referred to [Nat. Quaest. lib. vi. c. 1. Op. tom. iv. pp. 309?312. edit. Bipont.]; he speaks indeed of earthquakes, but only in a very cursory manner, and does not instance more than four or five, because his object was evidently not to write a history of them, but to investigate their symptoms, causes, and prognostics. The same remark applies to Pliny with respect to earthquakes. They are mentioned only to introduce philosophical observations. The historian, therefore, has but very feeble props to support his assertion. We may reasonably imagine, that if Seneca and Pliny have recorded all the great phenomena of nature, they must of course have explored the Grecian and Roman histories, which were immediately open to their inquiries. Now, let us try an experiment as to what they have derived from those sources with respect to eclipses. Do they mention the total eclipse of the sun, when the celebrated plague happened at Athens, in the first year of the Peloponnesian war? Do they mention the solar eclipse on the day when the foundations of Rome were laid? Do they mention the eclipse foretold by Thales, by which a peace was effected between the Medes and the Lydians? It would be too tedious and useless to ask for many others, which might be mentioned without any fear of our questions being answered in the affirmative.
THIRDLY, The distinct chapter of Pliny, in which, according to the historian?s lofty representation, we should expect to find the subject of eclipses exhausted by his full and elaborate detail, consists of only eighteen words, the purport of which is, that ?eclipses of the sun are sometimes of extraordinary duration; such as that which took place on the death of Caesar, and during the war with Antony, when the sun appeared pale for nearly a year.? [Fiunt prodigiosi, et longiores solis defectus: qualis occiso dictatore Caesare, et Antoniano bello, totius paene anni pallore continuo. Plin. Hist. Nat. lib. ii. c. 30. tom. i p. 148. edit. Bipont.]
LASTLY, This miraculous preternatural darkness did not pass without notice. Omitting the supposed attestation of it by Phlegon (a pagan chronologist who wrote during the reign of the emperor Hadrian [See Lardner's Works, vol. vii. pp. 370-387, 8vo.; or vol. iv. pp. 58-67, 4to.], and whose testimony is cited by Tertullian, Origen, and Eusebius), and also the supposed mention of it by Thallus (who lived in the second century), which is cited by Julius Africanus [Ibid.], a writer of great eminence and probity, who lived at the beginning of the third century;?we may remark that there are two other testimonies not founded on the statements of Phlegon and Thallus, which unequivocally confirm the evangelical history of the darkness at the crucifixion, viz. those of Tertullian and Celsus. In his Apology for the Christians, which was addressed to their heathen adversaries, Tertullian expressly says, ?At the moment of Christ's death, the light departed from the sun, and the land was darkened at noon-day; WHICH WONDER IS RELATED IN YOUR OWN ANNALS, AND IS PRESERVED IN YOUR ARCHIVES TO THIS DAY.? [Tertullian, Apol. c. 21.] If the account of this extraordinary darkness had not been registered, Tertullian would have exposed both himself to the charge of asserting a falsehood (which charge was never brought against him), and also his religion to the ridicule of his enemies. It is further particularly worthy of remark, that the darkness and earthquake at the crucifixion are both explicitly recognised and mentioned as FACTS by that acute adversary of Christianity, Celsus; who would not have made such an admission, if he could have possibly denied them. [See Origen contr. Celsum, lib. ii. § 55. p. 94.] -- pp. 185-86.
An Introduction to the Critical Study and Knowledge of the Holy Scriptures, Volume 2, 1825 edition,
1877 edition. Edited by Thomas Hartwell Horne, John Ayre and Samuel Prideaux Tregelles. 14th edition, London: Longmans, Green, 1877.
An Introduction to the Critical Study and Knowledge of the Holy Scriptures, Volume 3,
1825 edition,
1877 edition. Edited by Thomas Hartwell Horne, John Ayre and Samuel Prideaux Tregelles. 14th edition, London: Longmans, Green, 1877.
An Introduction to the Critical Study and Knowledge of the Holy Scriptures, Volume 4, 1825 edition.
1877 edition. Edited by Thomas Hartwell Horne, John Ayre and Samuel Prideaux Tregelles. 14th edition, London: Longmans, Green, 1877. Also here.
"To the library of every lover of the Holy Scriptures, who has the leisure to peruse it, this elaborate work will form a most valuable addition; but to the Biblical Student, and to young Ministers, it is at once indispensable and invaluable; no single work on any of the four main branches of Biblical Study which are here so copiously treated, having, we believe, ever issued from the press, which comprehends so much information in itself, or points out, by references so ample, where that information may be obtained without which the Scriptures can neither be fully understood, nor explained. Almost every author of note has been consulted by the industry of the Author, and the most important contributions of the learning, research, and observation of others, will be here found collected, and arranged with a sober and temperate judgment, and under the guidance of the light of evangelical truth. The last is an important circumstance, and renders the work safe as well as instructive." Wesleyan-Methodist Magazine, 1, June 1822, p.373.
An Introduction to the Study of Bibliography: to which is prefixed a memoir on the public libraries of the ancients. London, 1814. Volume 1 of 2. 429 pp. Volume 2 of 2. 531 pp.
Miscellaneous -- "Death of the Rev. Hartwell Horne". From North Wales Chronicle (Bangor, Wales), February 1, 1862; Issue 1815.
"We regret to announce the death of the Rev. Thomas Hartwell Horne, B.D. rector of the united parishes of St. Edmund the King and St. Nicholas Acons, Lombard-street, London. The reverend gentleman was the author of one of the most celebrated works in Biblical literature, 'An Introduction to the Critical Study of the Holy Scriptures.' So struck was Dr. Howley, bishop of London, with this work that he offered ordination to Mr. Horne, who was at the time devoting himself generally to the pursuits of literature. He held for many years an important literary appointment in the British Museum. His ordination took place in 1819, and for a long time he did parochial duty in London, chiefly at St. James's Church, Westmorland street, St. Marylebone. In 1833, Dr. Howley who had at that time become Archbishop of Canterbury, presented him to his city rectory, which he held up to the time of his death, which occured on Monday. Mr. Horne was in the 82d year of his age. -- Globe.
Apologist. Read more about Houtteville here. (In French)
WORKS
La religion chrétiene provée par les faits, par Mr. l'Abbé Houtteville. Nouvelle éd. Paris: G. Dupuis, 1740. Three volumes. Volume 1. Volume 2. Volume 3. Note: There is no English-language edition.
Avery Robert Dulles, A History of Apologetics, Ignatius Press, 2005: As the eighteenth century progress, French apologists, like their colleagues in England, showed an increasing tendency to shift their ground from philosophical reasoning to historical evidence. This development is already discernible in the work of the Oratorian Alexandre Claude Franois Houtteville (or Houteville; 1686-1742), who issued in 1722 The Christian Religion Proved by Facts. Book 1, the most original part of this work, demonstrates that the miraculous events narrated in the Gospels are worthy of acceptance according to the general laws of historical evidence. In the first place, he observes, since miracles are not self-contradictory, they are worthy of serious investigation (chapter 6). Further, the Gospel miracles are vouched for by contemporary eyewitnesses (chapter 7) who were sincere and truthful (chapter 8). The Gospel facts, moreover, were public and of general interest (chapter 9). They stand at the basis of certain later facts, such as the willingness of the early Christians to die for their faith (chapter 10). The miracles of Jesus were admitted by the Jews and pagans of the first Christian centuries, although it would have been to the interest of these adversaries to deny them (chapter 11). Finally, the miracle stories have been handed down without corruption (chapter 12). In Book 2 Houtteville sets forth the conventional arguments from Old Testament prophecies of Christ, and in Book 3 he replies to fourteen major objects raised by the deists to the veracity of the Gospels. At the end he appends a dissertation on the systems that the unbelievers propose as alternatives to Christianity.
Houtteville's work is clear and well ordered. His efforts to apply exact historical method to the Gospels represented a real advance, but the undeveloped state of historical science in his day has, of course, made his work quite obsolete by modern standards. (Footnote: For a good analysis of this work see Monod, De Pascal a Chateaubriand, 219-28).
"As there is no public worship in this place & Congress has at present no Chaplain, I have been witness to no act of public devotion since I have been here. The second night after my arrival being Saturday night, in the Edge of the evening the Servant brought into the room & set on the Table two candles & two packs of Cards. Some of the company soon spread around the Table & went to playing for money. I left the room & was shewed to another. After which I sent for Mr Ellery & we spent the Evening by ourselves. In conversation I observed to the Company that in N. England the Table would have been furnished with a bible & Psalm book instead of two packs of Cards.
"I was told the next day that they had played for ten to twenty guineas a game--and that one man had lost 200 guineas. Gentlemen here boast of such adventures. So widely different are the customs & manners of the people here from those of N. England.
"The older I grow the more I am impressed with the persuasion that religion is for the good of Society. If in this World only it had a reward, that reward would be sufficient to induce a reasonable man to become seriously religious: and the advantages Government would receive from the prevalence of some religion among the people are sufficient, in my opinion to induce every patriot, or good politician to countenance & encourage it by precept & example.
"I therefore cordially join you in wishing that we may ?build our future empire on the basis of religion, virtue & justice.?"
[Einleitung in die Schriften des Neuen Testaments - English] An Introduction to the Writings of the New Testament / by Johann Leonard Hug; translated from the original German by the Rev. Daniel Guildford Wait. London: C & J Rivington, 1827. Volume 1 of 2. Volume 2. 22 cm.
Plasma physicist, nuclear engineering educator. Head of Department of Nuclear Engineering, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, Massachusetts. Learn more about Hutchinson in the scientists of Christian faith feature.
WORKS
Science: Christian and Natural.
"I take the position that science and faith are complementary views of the world; that science studies the world insofar as it behaves in regular ways readily investigated using the reductionist methods of the physical sciences, and that theology finds its place along with many other disciplines, in understanding the human, personal, purposeful, and spiritual aspects of the world, which are not describable in reductionist terms."
"...the question arises, why did modern science grow up almost entirely in the West, where Christian thinking held sway? There were civilizations of comparable stability, prosperity, and in many cases technology, in China, Japan, and India. Why did they not develop science? It is acknowledged that arabic countries around the end of the first millenium were more advanced in mathematics, and their libraries kept safe eventually for Christendom much of the Greek wisdom of the ancients. Why did not their learning blossom into the science we now know? More particularly, if Andrew White's portrait of history, that the church dogmatically opposed all the 'dangerous innovations' of science, and thereby stunted scientific development for hundreds of years, why didn't science rapidly evolve in these other cultures?
"A case that has been made cogently by Stanley Jaki, amongst others, is that far from being an atmosphere stifling to science, the Christian world view of the West was the fertile cultural and philosophical soil in which science grew and flourished. He argues that it was precisely the theology of Christianity which created that fertile intellectual environment. The teaching that the world is the free but contingent creation of a rational Creator, worthy of study on its own merits because it is 'good', and the belief that because our rationality is in the image of the creator, we are capable of understanding the creation: these are theological encouragements to the work of empirical science. Intermingled with the desire to benefit humankind for Christian charity's sake, and enabled by the printing press to record and communicate results for posterity, the work of science became a force that gathered momentum despite any of the strictures of a threatened religious hierarchy."